I understand Magners problem and was very unlucky.

But if PC rule this type of case in favour of any boat discon then it will leave the door wide open for skippers to deliberately discon if it suits them?

Submission Type: Explanation 1.Your registered Boat Name: Blue Sweden TTW - Bad Guys 2.Race Day: 1 3.Group (colour): Green 4.Race (number): 2 5.Time (in Replay): 14:31.59 6.Rule(s) applicable: 17.1 7.Skipper(s) involved: Blue Sweden TTW / JohnPap HDT 8.Description: Whilst sailing on the reach with t...

Dear friends. After many seasons being involved in the PC for MLS, I have decided to step down from any PC position for any future series. The only reason for this decision is the lack of time i have to carry out the required work to the necessary level. I would like to thank all the previous and cu...

Facts at topmark : > Duffy and Josenrique are STB (Duffy is windward of Josenrique) > Cocal is on port > Cocal tacks leeward of Josenrique, outside of zone > Cocal go head to wind in order to pass the topmark > But between 13:01:97 and 13:03:45 (time in replay), Cocal tacks 2 times > Josenrique and...

Facts : > Damian, Oversteer and Marino are on port (downwind) > Damian is windward of Oversteer > Oversteer is windward of Mar There is a shift, Damian and Marino gybe. Oversteer receive RRS10 by Nadeo from Damian Decision > Damian can't gybe here because he doesn't give enough time to react to Ove...

Facts at topmark : > PKUlm is on port > Jepsom and Josenrique are STB > Jepsom is leeward of Josenrique > PKUlm give enough room for 2 boats When Jepsom tacks, Nadeo give a RRS10 to PKUlm Decision : >Pen was given by a Nadeo bug >Explanation ACCEPTED >No further action against PKUlm

Facts RiaDeVigo finished her tack somewhere between 13:28 and 13:32. Even taking the 'worst case scenario' (13:32) - Freja was at that time windward to RiaDeVigo. Freja should keep clear under RRS 11. There is room for Freja to keep clear, he does not try to do so. Decision: Explanation REJECTED Fr...

Facts before downwind mark : >LG'07 is behind and leeward of Wetstuff 21:34 : LG'07 luffs Wetstuff and sails above the axis of the mark 21:37 : Nadeo give RRS17.1 to LG'07 LG'07 asks to cancel his pen, wetstuff accepts. LG'07 turns around the mark. 22:08 : LG'07 finishs his spinnaker maneuver 22:16...