Thank you for the question...we will look again and issue an explanation.


MLS PC

Facts before start : Batboat and Zhik are STB, Batboat is in front of Zhik 00:35 : Zhik and Batboat luff both (Zhik luff harder than Batboat and becomes windward of Batboat) 00:36 : Zhik bear away in order to try to be leeward of Batboat and there is a collision Nadeo give RRS15 against Batboat Bat...

Facts before the topmark : > Damian is on port > Tiki is on port too and he's leeward of Damian > Legsy is STB When Legsy is close to Tiki, all the boats in this case (Legsy, Tiki and Damian) are outside the area of 2 lengths boat Tiki tries to tack (and call RTT meant for Damian as he said in his ...

Facts before topmark : Ryh00 and Jepsom are on port, Jepsom is behind Ryh00. Ryh00 bear away in order to pass behind Goffe and Pajaro Next, Ryh00 tacks, Jepsom tacks again slowly and there is a collision between Ryh00 and Jepsom There are 4 seconds between "Ryh00 finish his tack" (13:41) ...

Facts before topmark : > After the mess, PKUlm has a 360 > PKUlm is on port > Batboat is STB 12:55 : PKUlm begins his tack in front of Batboat 12:58 : PKUlm finish his tack 12;59 : Batboat is faster and must luff in order to avoid collision with PKUlm Batboat protest against PKUlm On reach, PKUlm d...

Facts: Defender and Duffy were approaching wind ward mark on port tack. Both boats had to tack to starboard to fetch the mark. Duffy had windward and inside overlap to Defender when Defender was entering the zone. Therefore Defender had to give mark room to Duffy (rule 18.2.b) Decision: Defender br...

Facts : Tulle is leeward and behind of Jonte. Lots of boats are windward of Jonte First, Tulle doesn't luff Jonte, but when they approach the mark, Tulle can go to the mark he can luff Jonte (just in order to go to the mark) Decision RRS17.1 given by Nadeo is incorrect Tulle Explanation ACCEPTED No...

Facts just before rounding the mark : Excalibur is leeward of Valodea, Valodea is leeward of Orione, Orione is leeward of Jonte Valodea was behind Excalibur after previous mark, so he can't luff Exalibur (RRS17.1) But Valodea must keep clear of Jonte and Orione to round the mark (RRS18) Decision : ...

Facts : approaching top mark BatBoat and 103 SPX are STB, 103 SPX is leeward of Batboat. 103 SPX tacks further than the layline in order to give enough room for Batboat. 103 SPX tries to luff in order to give even more room for Batboat, but Batboat give an RRS10 for 103 SPX 103 SPX ask, Batboat acc...