Search found 57 matches

by Spirillen
Sat Apr 20, 2019 7:27 pm
Forum: Race Day 4
Topic: Season 9, Day 4, Red Server, Race 2, Cancel explaination
Replies: 2
Views: 5216

Re: Season 9, Day 4, Red Server, Race 2, Cancel explaination

Spirillen hoisted her spinnaker, Petter did same. When they had their ”spi” set up, Spirillen broached for a very short moment and immediately re-took control of her boat. Petter had no adequate room to keep clear due to the fact that she was way way to close windward to Spirillen. Decision : Petter...
by Spirillen
Sat Apr 20, 2019 7:26 pm
Forum: Race Day 4
Topic: MLS-s9_gRED_Day4_Race2_Explanation
Replies: 1
Views: 4551

Re: MLS-s9_gRED_Day4_Race2_Explanation

PC agrees with Ed himself, that the pen was correct, and would thank him for making the PC work easier.

Decision:
Ed DSQ for breaking RRS 13
No further action against Djonny

PC for MLS
by Spirillen
Sat Apr 20, 2019 7:25 pm
Forum: Race Day 4
Topic: MLS S9 Day 4, Red, Race 2, P
Replies: 1
Views: 4767

Re: MLS S9 Day 4, Red, Race 2, P

Looking at replay, Jepsom had overtaken Wetstuff to windward. Jepsom breaks the overlap, and later Wetstuff establishes an overlap again, to leeward with in 2 boat lenghts, so Wetstuff is uner RRS 17. At the replay it doesn't seems, that Wetstuff is sailing higher than prober course, so Wtstuff do n...
by Spirillen
Sat Apr 20, 2019 7:24 pm
Forum: Race Day 4
Topic: Season 9, Day 4, Red Server, Race 3 Cancel Explaination
Replies: 1
Views: 4519

Re: Season 9, Day 4, Red Server, Race 3 Cancel Explaination

Petter to windward of Nick, and overlapped, both on port. Starboard boat coming (an obstruction), and Nick starts to go behind, but leaves no room for Petter. Further more, Nick starts to tack just after he passes behind the obstruction, giving Petter no time or opportunity to keep clear of Nick. Bu...
by Spirillen
Sat Apr 20, 2019 7:23 pm
Forum: Race Day 4
Topic: MLS Season 9, Day 4, Race 2 Protest and redress
Replies: 1
Views: 4650

Re: MLS Season 9, Day 4, Race 2 Protest and redress

Fiducit pen cancel explanation : ACCEPTED as Valodea had time to respond to Fiducit luff, but Valodea kept the same heading until the very last moment before a collision would occurred. Valodea breaks MLS Rules for not accepting a pen cancel request which is mandatory. Decision: Fiducit pen cancel a...
by Spirillen
Sat Apr 20, 2019 7:22 pm
Forum: Race Day 4
Topic: mls s9 day 4 server red , race 3 , explanation
Replies: 1
Views: 4563

Re: mls s9 day 4 server red , race 3 , explanation

Frenito has no rights to tack there, since no RTT call.

Decision:
Frenito pen cancel not accepted, Frenito DSQ for breaking RRS 15 and RRS 18.2a.
Remm3y no action.

PC for MLS
by Spirillen
Sat Apr 20, 2019 7:21 pm
Forum: Race Day 4
Topic: Season 9, Day 4, Red Server, Race 1, Cancel explaination
Replies: 1
Views: 4520

Re: Season 9, Day 4, Red Server, Race 1, Cancel explaination

- Frenito doesn't break RRS15 here - Petter tacks and enters in zone without being established. It should have passed behind Frenito and Spirillen, and give Room to Duck to Winslow. He doesn't ! So Petter DSQ for breaking RRS18 (with Frenito), RRS15 and RRS 19 (with Winslow) - Winslow must pass behi...
by Spirillen
Sat Apr 20, 2019 7:20 pm
Forum: Race Day 4
Topic: MLS Season9, Race Day 4, Blue Group, Race #1, E,P.
Replies: 3
Views: 6456

Re: MLS Season9, Race Day 4, Blue Group, Race #1, E,P.

Fiducit in his reply, himself writes that he had atleast 5 second, from RTT call, until he responded (by "YT")
That is not reacting promptly, and he therefore breaks RRS 20.

Decision:
Jammin pen cancel accepted, no further action.
Fiducit DSQ for breaking RRS 13 and RRS 20.

PC for MLS
by Spirillen
Wed Apr 10, 2019 6:43 pm
Forum: Race Day 4
Topic: Season 9, Day 4, Red Server, Race 2, Cancel explaination
Replies: 2
Views: 5216

Re: Season 9, Day 4, Red Server, Race 2, Cancel explaination

Yes I took a pen turn, as soon as I could, just to be sure. But looking at replay, Petter is so close to windward, that there are immediately contact, when I changed course because of the small brough. So, in my eyes, Petter broke RRS 11, I just took the pen turn as a precaution, if the PC finds tha...
by Spirillen
Thu Apr 04, 2019 7:18 pm
Forum: Race Day 3
Topic: MLS Season09-Day3, Pen Cancels and Chat Pens, 2019-03-26
Replies: 1
Views: 4560

Re: MLS Season09-Day3, Pen Cancels and Chat Pens, 2019-03-26

MLS Season09 Day3, Cancel Requests, Manual Protests and Redress Requests 2019-03-26 Time (in game) Cancel/Protest Boat asking/protesting Boat cancelling/protested Rule Comment Blue Group Race 1, de light-MLS 27:50 C Orione/Lupidimare Piotr1970/POL-VSC 16.1 Orione pen cancel accepted, Piottr DSQ for...

Go to advanced search