Submission Type: RDG
1. Your registered boat name: Siwy-pol
2. Group: Red
3. Race (number): 1
4. Time of incident (in replay): 16,24
5. Rule(s) applicable: 17.1
6. Boat(s) involved: Fran:Loyal
7. Description: I was sailing at full course, Fran swimming slightly ahead to the right. On the left, a shuraz was sailing slightly behind, and I had no room to turn from right to left tack. I got 17.1 wrongly and asked for the penalty to be canceled. Fran didn't cancel the penalty so in a moment I got another penalty after exceeding the time limit, so I am asking for Refress requests
8. Print Screen attached (required for a manual protest):
9. Replay attached (recommended):
Redress Requests Final day Race 3 Red
Redress Requests Final day Race 3 Red
- Attachments
-
- Taxi Driver 2(03'02''00).Replay.Gbx
- (2.9 MiB) Downloaded 227 times
-
- Zrzut ekranu (184).png (1.22 MiB) Viewed 2243 times
Re: Redress Requests Final day Race 3 Red
Facts:
Siwy sailed a proper course when VSK assigned a penalty under rule 17.1. Siwy requested cancellation, but Fran did not approve. Siwy was in 11th place (excluding Fran) when the time limit for cancellation had run out.
Conclusion:
Siwy did not break any rules.
Fran broke MLS Rule 3.2.2 for not approving the cancellation request.
Decision:
Siwy is given 11 points as redress.
Fran to be disqualified in the race.
The protest committee
Siwy sailed a proper course when VSK assigned a penalty under rule 17.1. Siwy requested cancellation, but Fran did not approve. Siwy was in 11th place (excluding Fran) when the time limit for cancellation had run out.
Conclusion:
Siwy did not break any rules.
Fran broke MLS Rule 3.2.2 for not approving the cancellation request.
Decision:
Siwy is given 11 points as redress.
Fran to be disqualified in the race.
The protest committee