Submission Type:
1. Your registered Boat Name: Duffy
2. Race Day: 3
3. Group: BLUE
4. Race : )
5. Time (in Replay): 2:52
6. Rule(s) applicable: 16.1. - 20.2.b- - c.
7. Skipper(s) involved: Duffy - Kokos
8. Description: Duffy (leewards and with overlap) and Kokos (windwards) on port tack meets A2-mover on starboard tack. Duffy asked "RTT" in good time, but Kokos does not responds and after several seconds Duffe starts tacking to avoid collision with A2-mover. While tacking Duffy gets a 16.1. pen from Kokos, who does still not react. Duffy asks cancel for 16.1., which Kokos accept.
Duffy protest against Kokos for not responding properly to RTT - see screenshot.
9. Print Screen attached: (required for a valid PROTEST) Y
10. Replay attached: (optional) Y
MLS season 10 Day 3 BLUE server Race 9 Duffy vs. Kokos 16.1.
MLS season 10 Day 3 BLUE server Race 9 Duffy vs. Kokos 16.1.
- Attachments
-
- ScreenShot27.bmp (4.69 MiB) Viewed 6645 times
-
- MLS 103-3- Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere_v3(03'00''70).Replay.Gbx
- (2.91 MiB) Downloaded 501 times
Re: MLS season 10 Day 3 BLUE server Race 9 Duffy vs. Kokos 16.1.
Case still Pending
Re: MLS season 10 Day 3 BLUE server Race 9 Duffy vs. Kokos 16.1.
Suggested Text:
Facts :
> Kokos is on port, and windward of Duffy
> Duffy is on port, and leeward of Kokos
> A2-Mover is STB
> Duffy asks RTT to Kokos
> Duffy and Kokos tacks in same time, and there is a collision
> Nadeo give RRS16.1 to Duffy
> Duffy asks to cancel his pen, and he protests against Kokos
> Kokos accepts, but he doesn't respond to the Duffy's protest.
Kokos had enough time to respond to Duffy hail. Duffy had to eventually tack to avoid A-2. Only then did Kokos tack. If Kokos had reacted in good time Duffy would not have received any penalty from Nadeo.
Decision:
Kokos DSQ for RRS 20.2.c
Duffy Pen Cancel Accepted, No further action
MLS PC
Facts :
> Kokos is on port, and windward of Duffy
> Duffy is on port, and leeward of Kokos
> A2-Mover is STB
> Duffy asks RTT to Kokos
> Duffy and Kokos tacks in same time, and there is a collision
> Nadeo give RRS16.1 to Duffy
> Duffy asks to cancel his pen, and he protests against Kokos
> Kokos accepts, but he doesn't respond to the Duffy's protest.
Kokos had enough time to respond to Duffy hail. Duffy had to eventually tack to avoid A-2. Only then did Kokos tack. If Kokos had reacted in good time Duffy would not have received any penalty from Nadeo.
Decision:
Kokos DSQ for RRS 20.2.c
Duffy Pen Cancel Accepted, No further action
MLS PC