MLS S11, Race Day 5, Also ran, Race F3, Submission Type E

[Q23 SUI 007]

Submission Type: E

1.Your registered Boat Name: ElMoro

2.Race Day: 5

3.Group (colour): Also ran (red)

4.Race (number): F3

5.Time (in Replay): 13:15

6.Rule(s) applicable: 13

7.Skipper(s) involved: Tulle

8.Description: ElMoro finished her tack to starboard at 13:13, Tulle, on port-tack, started to tack at 13:14. At 13:15 ElMoro gets a Pen 16.1 which was wrong, I think. Tulle didn't keep clear while tacking so there was a violation of rule 13.

9.Print Screen attached (required for a valid PROTEST):

10.Replay attached (optional): Yes

Q23 SUI 007 on behalf of ElMoro

[PC Admin]

Facts at topmark :
> ElMoro is on port, ducks behind Cocal, and tacks in order to be STB
> ElMoro finish is tack at 13:12
> Tulle is on port, and tack at 13:14
> There is mast hit between Tulle and ElMoro, and ElMoro receives RRS16.1
> ElMoro cancels his pen, and nobody does 360

Decision :
> RRS16.1 is completly wrong here
> ElMoro's explanation ACCEPTED
> Tulle DSQ for breaking RRS10
> No further action

MLS PC