Submission Type: E - Cancelation explanation
1.Your registered Boat Name: Duffy
2.Race Day: 2
3.Group (colour): GREEN
4.Race (number): 3
5.Time (in Replay): 12:26
6.Rule(s) applicable: 11
7.Boat(s) involved:Jimi and Duffy
8.Description: Duffy is on starboard tack fetching wind ward mark with some small minor course adjustments. Jimi is on port tack and is bearing away to go behind Duffy, and while doing this Jimi hits Duffy and thereby breaking rule 11, while Nadeo umpire gives Duffy penalty 16.1.
Duffy asks for cancelation for 16.1., and Jimi accept this.
9.Print Screen attached (required for a manual protest): N
10.Replay attached (required):y MLS2020-6 Shallow.Replay.Gbx
MLS season 12 Day 2 GREEN server Race 3 Duffy vs. Jimi rule 11
MLS season 12 Day 2 GREEN server Race 3 Duffy vs. Jimi rule 11
- Attachments
-
- MLS2020-6 Shallow.Replay.Gbx
- (3.33 MiB) Downloaded 330 times
Re: MLS season 12 Day 2 GREEN server Race 3 Duffy vs. Jimi rule 11
Hi Duffy , Protest committee and all e sailors.
My replay attached below shows there was no contact on my screen. The penalty received by Duffy was due to lag and nobody broke any rule here.
Regards
Jimi
My replay attached below shows there was no contact on my screen. The penalty received by Duffy was due to lag and nobody broke any rule here.
Regards
Jimi
- Attachments
-
- Shallow-MLS PROTEST.Replay.Gbx
- (3.32 MiB) Downloaded 335 times
Re: MLS season 12 Day 2 GREEN server Race 3 Duffy vs. Jimi rule 11
Facts:
Duffy on starboard bears away slightly.
Jimi on port bears away to pass behind Duffy.
On Jimi's replay, he pass clear astern.
On host replay, he pass clear astern.
On Duffy's replay, Jimi hit Duffy 1/4 boat length from the stern.
Duffy got a penalty from the VSK umpire under rule 16.1 which he cancels.
Conclusion:
According to the MLS rules, it shall be considered as contact when there has been a penalty under rule 16.1 except if there was extra ordinary lag involved. In this case, the difference between Duffy's replay and the other replays were extra ordinary. Duffy gave room to keep clear on his replay. Jimi kept clear on his replay. No rules broken.
MLS Protest Committee
Duffy on starboard bears away slightly.
Jimi on port bears away to pass behind Duffy.
On Jimi's replay, he pass clear astern.
On host replay, he pass clear astern.
On Duffy's replay, Jimi hit Duffy 1/4 boat length from the stern.
Duffy got a penalty from the VSK umpire under rule 16.1 which he cancels.
Conclusion:
According to the MLS rules, it shall be considered as contact when there has been a penalty under rule 16.1 except if there was extra ordinary lag involved. In this case, the difference between Duffy's replay and the other replays were extra ordinary. Duffy gave room to keep clear on his replay. Jimi kept clear on his replay. No rules broken.
MLS Protest Committee