MLS S12 - Day 4 - Blue Server - Race 3 - Cancel Explanation
Posted: Wed Nov 25, 2020 5:10 pm
Submission Type: E
1.Your registered Boat Name: Jimi
2.Race Day: 4
3.Group (colour): Blue Server
4.Race (number): 3
5.Time (in Replay): 01:48:00
6.Rule(s) applicable: 10, 13 and 22.2 instead of 16.1
7.Boat(s) involved: Jimi and Duffy
8.Description:
Duffy was on port before start, and received RRS10 from Fiducit.
Duffy decided to do his penalty turn, and Jimi had to luff for the first time in order to avoid contact
Then, Duffy didn't complete his penalty turn, and tacked to solve it.
Jimi had to luff for the second time in order to avoid again Duffy.
Then, Duffy tacked again to be STB, and there was mast hit between Duffy and Jimi.
Jimi received RRS16.1, asked to cancel, and Duffy accepted.
So IMO, I think Duffy broke :
- RRS10 and RRS22.2 when there was Jimi's first luff
- RRS10 when there was Jimi's second luff
- RRS13 when there was mast hit between both boats
9.Print Screen attached (required for a manual protest): N
10.Replay attached (recommended): Toppen on behalf of Jimi
1.Your registered Boat Name: Jimi
2.Race Day: 4
3.Group (colour): Blue Server
4.Race (number): 3
5.Time (in Replay): 01:48:00
6.Rule(s) applicable: 10, 13 and 22.2 instead of 16.1
7.Boat(s) involved: Jimi and Duffy
8.Description:
Duffy was on port before start, and received RRS10 from Fiducit.
Duffy decided to do his penalty turn, and Jimi had to luff for the first time in order to avoid contact
Then, Duffy didn't complete his penalty turn, and tacked to solve it.
Jimi had to luff for the second time in order to avoid again Duffy.
Then, Duffy tacked again to be STB, and there was mast hit between Duffy and Jimi.
Jimi received RRS16.1, asked to cancel, and Duffy accepted.
So IMO, I think Duffy broke :
- RRS10 and RRS22.2 when there was Jimi's first luff
- RRS10 when there was Jimi's second luff
- RRS13 when there was mast hit between both boats
9.Print Screen attached (required for a manual protest): N
10.Replay attached (recommended): Toppen on behalf of Jimi