Submission Type: Cancel Explanation
1.Your registered Boat Name: Sailor-GER Loyal Team
2.Race Day: 2
3.Group (colour): blue
4.Race (number): 1
5.Time (in Replay): 9:27
6.Rule(s) applicable: 12
7.Boat(s) involved: Sailor-GER Loyal / Damian HDT Fishing Team
8.Description: Damien was near behind me and wanted to fall away. Damien touched my rear end and got a penalty of 12. I canceled the penalty upon request.
9.Print Screen attached (required for a manual protest):
10.Replay attached (required):
Season 12 Race Day 2 Group Blue Race 1 - Cancel Explanation
-
- Posts: 29
- Joined: Fri Sep 07, 2018 10:57 pm
-
- Posts: 301
- Joined: Wed Oct 31, 2018 4:58 am
Season 12 Race Day 2 Group Blue Race 1 - Cancel Explanation
Submission Type: Cancel Explanation
1.Your registered Boat Name: Damian
2.Race Day: 2
3.Group (colour): blue
4.Race (number): 1
5.Time (in Replay): around 11:00
6.Rule(s) applicable: 11
7.Boat(s) involved: Sailor Ger
8.Description: (I write this post on behalf of Damian as he cannot connect to the forum)
I was approaching the windward mark overlapped to windward of Sailor Ger. I tried to sail under him and I was penalized by the umpire for rule 12, which i asked to cancel and sailor accepted...
The only reason i asked to cancel is that the penalty was wrong as the boats were overlapped. I did break rule 11 and that is why soon after I did a penalty turn as you can see on the replay around 11:20
9.Print Screen attached (required for a manual protest):
10.Replay attached (required):
1.Your registered Boat Name: Damian
2.Race Day: 2
3.Group (colour): blue
4.Race (number): 1
5.Time (in Replay): around 11:00
6.Rule(s) applicable: 11
7.Boat(s) involved: Sailor Ger
8.Description: (I write this post on behalf of Damian as he cannot connect to the forum)
I was approaching the windward mark overlapped to windward of Sailor Ger. I tried to sail under him and I was penalized by the umpire for rule 12, which i asked to cancel and sailor accepted...
The only reason i asked to cancel is that the penalty was wrong as the boats were overlapped. I did break rule 11 and that is why soon after I did a penalty turn as you can see on the replay around 11:20
9.Print Screen attached (required for a manual protest):
10.Replay attached (required):
- Attachments
-
- MLS_S12_Day2_ServerBlue_Race1.Replay.Gbx
- (3.27 MiB) Downloaded 331 times
Re: Pen Cancel
Topics merged.
Will, it's the boat requesting to cancel who has to submit an explanation, the boat accepting to cancel does not have the burden.
Harald
Will, it's the boat requesting to cancel who has to submit an explanation, the boat accepting to cancel does not have the burden.
Harald
Re: Season 12 Race Day 2 Group Blue Race 1 - Cancel Explanation
Facts:
Damian 1/5 of a boat width to windward of Sailorger's stern.
Sailorger bear away slowly and there is immediate contact on Sailorger's windward side.
Damian get a penalty from VSK under rule 12 which he cancels.
Daminan take a turn 20 seconds later.
Conclusion:
Damian did not keep clear and broke rule 11.
Damian took a penalty according to rule 44.2.
No action to be taken.
Note:
The PC receive alot of work for each regatta. That is no problem. But please do not give use more paperwork to process than necessary. Sailorger should not have submitted a topic for Damians explanation!
MLS Protest Committee
Damian 1/5 of a boat width to windward of Sailorger's stern.
Sailorger bear away slowly and there is immediate contact on Sailorger's windward side.
Damian get a penalty from VSK under rule 12 which he cancels.
Daminan take a turn 20 seconds later.
Conclusion:
Damian did not keep clear and broke rule 11.
Damian took a penalty according to rule 44.2.
No action to be taken.
Note:
The PC receive alot of work for each regatta. That is no problem. But please do not give use more paperwork to process than necessary. Sailorger should not have submitted a topic for Damians explanation!
MLS Protest Committee